Sarah Agor
— Katie (segment "My BFF")
Kimberly Atkinson
— Kim (segment "Dollface")
Ari Bavel
— Burt (segment "Get Off My Porch")
Stephen Blackehart
— Frank (segment "My BFF")
Mike Brabender
— Bearded Man (segment "Howl of a Good Time")
Sally Bremenkamp
— Woman {segment "Get Off My Porch")
Steve Brewster
— The Gentleman (segment "Good Evening")
Jessi Burkette
— The Babysitter
Sean Carmichael
— Donnie (segment "Tickle")
Franco Castan
— Arnold (segment "The Judas Cradle")
Jen Dede
— Emily (segment "Dollface")
Morgan Collar
— Brianne (segment "Howl of a Good Time")
Leslie Easterbrook
— Martha (segment "Howl of a Good Time")
Meagan Flynn
— Dazed Neighbor 2 (segment "Get Off My Porch")
Renae Geerlings
— Amanda (segment "Howl of a Good Time")
Tamara Glynn
— Simone (segment "Howl of a Good Time")
Isla Parker Hale
— Mary (segment "Howl of a Good Time")
Zoe Sofia Hale
— Anne (segment "Howl of a Good Time) (as Zoe Hale)
Dennis J. Healy
— Tic Tac (segment "Tickle")
Nick Holmes
— Nick (segment "Dollface")
Ty Jones
— News Reporter (segment "Get Off My Porch")
Chloë Kerwin
Aaron Laue
— Dazed Neighbor 1 (segment "Get Off My Porch")
Chris Lazzaro
— Vinnie (segment "Howl of a Good Time")
John Edward Lee
— Belial (segment "The Judas Cradle") (as Johnny Lee)
Andrew Lyndaker
— Charlie (segment "Tickle")
Kayla Madison
— Madeline (segment "My BFF")
Roma Maffia
— Karen (segment "Dollface")
Katherine McNamara
— Mary (segment "Get Off My Porch")
Bradley Meehan
— Neil (segment: "Get Off My Porch")