Kipp Marcus
— James Ellis
Alice Dylan
— Sarah Milson
Bernadette Peters
— Elise Ellis
Larry Pine
— Wendell Milson
Henry Simmons
— Mitch Jennings
Judith Malina
— Grammy
Miriam Shor
— Beth
Michael Ornstein
— Lenny Ellis
Season Oglesby
— Betsy Clotworthy
Debra Sullivan
— Patricia Milson
Peter Giles
— Peter
Sandra Prosper
— Jenny
Adam Marcus
— Fascist French Chef
Kristopher Scott Fiedel
— James at 4
Ned Eisenberg
— Carl
Missi Pyle
— Ily
Stephen Colbert
— Happy Successful Guy
Mary Birdsong
— Sneakered Businesswoman
Nadya Ginsburg
— Store Owner
Jordi Caballero
— Jean-Claude