Rita Hayworth
— Josephine Brown / Jo Morris
Anthony Franciosa
— Victor Santini
Gig Young
— Larry Ellis
Mildred Dunnock
— Mrs. Ellis
Hugh Griffith
— Judge Edgar Neilsen
Sanford Meisner
— Phil Stanley
Robert Burton
— District Attorney Nordeau
Alfred Ryder
— Lt. Mike Morris
Katherine Squire
— Mrs. Hattie Brown
Raymond Greenleaf
— Judge Carey
Myrna Fahey
— Alice
Leo Penn
— Morrie Goetz
Sheridan Comerate
— Ofcr. Francis Morris
Jay Adler
— Lauber (uncredited)
Joe Besser
— Gallagher (uncredited)
Virginia Carroll
— Police Matron (uncredited)
Harry Carter
— Seth (Court Bailiff) (uncredited)
William Challee
— Lemke (uncredited)
Jack Chefe
— Courtroom Spectator (uncredited)
Bru Danger
— Cook (uncredited)
Biff Elliot
— Eddie Ritter (uncredited)
Franklyn Farnum
— Juror (uncredited)
Valerie French
— Liz (uncredited)
Leonard George
— Jury Foreman (uncredited)
Richard George
— Courtroom Spectator (uncredited)
Tom Greenway
— Detective Captain Kelly (uncredited)
Stuart Holmes
— Juror (uncredited)
Miranda Jones
— Miss Monroe (uncredited)
Colin Kenny
— Courtroom Spectator (uncredited)
Mike Lally
— Courtroom Reporter (uncredited)