Michael Rooker
— Father Vassey
Leslie Hope
— Jenny Hatcher
Shawn Thompson
— Sheriff Sam Logan
Andrew Jackson
— Shadowbuilder
Kevin Zegers
— Chris Hatcher
Tony Todd
— Evert Covey
Hardee T. Lineham
— Nestor Tibbot (as Hardee Lineham)
Catherine Bruhier
— Maggie MacKinnon
Gordon Michael Woolvett
— Larry Eggers (as Gordon M. Woolvett)
James B. Douglas
— Doc Cole
Richard McMillan
— Father Finler
Charlotte Sullivan
— Jazz
Andrew Sardella
— Paul
David Calderisi
— Bishop Gallo
Lawrence Bayne
— Quinlan
Eric Murphy
— Vic Lambert
Paul Soles
— Mr. Butterman
Billie Mae Richards
— Mrs. Butterman
Nicole Stoffman
— Kelly
Toby Proctor
— Harvey Price
Tara Crooks
— Lizzie
Steve Blum
— Shadowbuilder (voice) (as Steven Blum)
Matt Birman
— Cult Member (uncredited)
Brian Kowalchuk
— Drunk Man (uncredited)
Trevor Lawson
— Fighting Man (uncredited)
C.J. Lusby
— Streaker (uncredited)