Robert Knepper
— Detective Jim Hamell
Carrie Preston
— Carol Jensen
Guillermo Díaz
— Rodney Alcala
Tanya van Graan
— Shauna Bradshaw
Frances Sholto-Douglas
— Lori Carter
Matt Barr
— Detective Ryan
Kim Suzanne Engelbrecht
— Joanne
Meganne Young
— Wendy Cade
Athena Strates
— Camper Kaye
Alma Martinez
— Anna Alcala
Darrell Fetty
— Donald Haines
Daniah De Villiers
— Tammy Jensen
Deon Lotz
— Camp Director Lee
Grant Ross
— Superior Court Clerk
Trix Vivier
— Susan's Friend in Club
Kate Liquorish
— Judith O'Reilly
Camilla Wolfson
— Helen Vogel
Byron Langley
— Tyler
Lee Raviv
— Becky Wilkins
Gina Shmukler
— Rosie Hoffman
Dominika Jablonska
— Susan Babineau
Lily Spangenberg
— Young Rosie
Mark Wijsman
— Jury Foreman
Greg Parvess
— Park Ranger
Jamie Anders
— Courtroom Attendee
Jessica Dawson
— Pamela
Taryn Uria
— Sophie
Chelsea du Toit
— Camper Kaye