Mark Cray
— John Craven
Devin Kates
— Seth Hayden
Kati Jordan
— Holly Craven
Jonathan Adam Duerr
— Alex / Masked Victim
Kyle Znamenak
— Vince
Mike Hinkle
— Christian
Tom Allen
— Kyle
Kevin Ashley
— Chester Donnell
Rebecca Lynne
— Nicki
Erica Soto
— Victim
Ashley Henke
— Victim
Sarah Domanick
— Victim
Danielle Cray
— Danielle
Jessica Hsu
— Victim
Bill McCue
— Victim
Tony Kates
— Robert Hayden
Amanda Hughes
— Victim
James Flahart
— Victim
Fearon Derry
— Newscaster (voice)
Anne Reiss
— Kaylah
Beth Kates
— Samantha Hayden
David M. Sitbon
— Grey Mortimer
Tiffeny Cray
— Girl
Dakota Skye Kates
— Robin Hayden
Jay Cusack
— Jeffrey
Anthony Mecca
— Eligio Bonelli
Ambrosia Cray
— Girl
Joseph Drobezko
— Victim
Nina Kates
— Tara Hayden
Steve Brown
— Pastor Vernon Cole