Lane Janger
— Anthony
Joelle Carter
— Amy
Guillermo Díaz
— Victor
Jennifer Esposito
— Michelle
David Lee Russek
— Dom
Vincent Laresca
— Nick
Domenick Lombardozzi
— Cyrill
Lázaro Pérez
— Luis
Lynn Cohen
— Sophia
Achilles Tsakiridis
— Mr. Zafiris
June Kessler
— Candy
Phyllis Somerville
— Scratchy-voiced Woman
Priscilla Lopez
— Mrs. De-Jesus
Chris Stewart
— Bartender
André Vippolis
— Fireboy
Harley Kaplan
— Fireboy's Friend
Jerran Friedman
— Young Man in Bathroom
Hazelle Goodman
— Lesbian Book Group Leader
Anastasia Sharp
— Sniffing Lesbian
Coco McPherson
— Bookstore Sales Clerk
Ajay Mehta
— Husan
Brandon Segarra
— Clarence
Susan Kellermann
— Anthony's Mom / Nava Hannibal (Amy's Mom)
Craig Chester
— Caterer
Mickey Cottrell
— Father Sebastian
Reathel Bean
— Nelson Hannibal
Pat Moya
— Mona
Rashawn Pringle
— Clarence's Friend