Rachel Brosnahan
— Wren Miller
Aidan Quinn
— Moody Burkhart
Seth Gilliam
— Officer Payne
M. Emmet Walsh
— Walter Lemke
Olympia Dukakis
— Margaret Lemke
Mary Beth Hurt
— Jo Ann Bayberry
Peter Gerety
— Arnie Bayberry
Satya Bhabha
— Josh Kassouni
Macy Gray
— Donna Olson
Rachel Zeiger-Haag
— Alison
Ronald Peet
— Student
Phil Nee
— Older Mailman
Jonathan Randell Silver
— Troubled Person
Gilbert Cruz
— Neighbor Witness
Amorika Amoroso
— Receptionist
Sulekha Naidu
— Pharmacist
Kimberly L. Jackson
— Neighbor
Eric Lockley
— Student
Yohancé Primus
— Teenager
Joe Alo
— Police Officer
Juliet Schlefer
— Student
James Zeiss
— Police Officer (uncredited)