Mischa Barton
— Samantha
Tara Reid
— Young Katherine
Carly Schroeder
— Laurie Fields
Dee Wallace
— Katherine Fields
Chris Mulkey
— Tomas
Mark Grossman
— Nick
Grace Demarco
— Tina
Derrick A. King
— Spence
Justin Hawkins
— Roka
Tiffany Shepis
— Claire
Nathaniel Meek
— Young Tomas
Kris N. Holmes
— Jane the Head Witch
Avery Austin
— Alice the Good Witch
Suzanne Riley-Whyte
— Susan the Good Witch
Shannon Sauceda
— Rebecca the Spy Witch
Sarah French
— Sarah the Evil Witch
Eva Hamilton
— Ada the Evil Witch
Susan Slaughter
— Sophia the Evil Witch
Brian Nagel
— Villager Husband Jacob
Nicole Holland
— Nora the Good Witch