Jonah Beres
— Arden
Austin Iredale
— Mr. Stevens
Kate Fuglei
— Sister Maria
Paul Alfaro
— Audience
Sean Beebe
— Orphan
Lisa George Bell
— Audience
Jaden Leyendecker
— Boy's Choir Member
Carson Severson
— Joe
Dan Colman
— Mr. Johnson
Dan Colman
— Mrs. Johnson
Joe Geragi
— Deacon
Evangeline Neuhart
— Nun
Rosalie Roder
— Nun
Gavin Peretti
— Priest