Tom Everett Scott
— Nick Pearson
Tituss Burgess
— The Amazing Fabular
Julian Feder
— Mason
Rachel Boston
— Sydney Bartlett
Rhea Seehorn
— Kelly
Andrew Bowen
— Richard
Julie Ann Emery
— Joanna
Maria de Lourdes Severny
— Carla Intinoli
Emily De Margheriti
— Daisy
Arden Myrin
— Janice Bodicker
Chris Levine
— Winifred 'Winny'/Freddy
Marisa Tomei
— Christine Hurley
Beth Riesgraf
— Schyler Cross
Ray Abruzzo
— Walter
Joyce Bulifant
— Betty Bartlett
Roger Perry
— Phil Bartlett
Bryan Batt
— Reverend McGooley
Nathan Arenas
— Frankie
Michael McHale
— Deejay
Lewie Bartone
— Chaz
Johnny Visotcky
— Jimmy
Bo Foxworth
— Dad
Jeris Poindexter
— Attendant
Patrice Barrie
— Old Annie
Rico E. Anderson
— CHP Officer
Daisy Traina
— Karate Girl
David Loden
— Delivery Room Doctor
Tiffany Yvonne Cox
— Delivery Room Nurse #1
Mary Hollis Inboden
— Delivery Room Nurse #2
Todd Traina
— Psychic #1