John Goodman
— Mr. Wellington
Jimmy Bennett
— Moon Blake
Clint Howard
— Constable Sanders
Gabriel Basso
— Hal Mitchell
Uriah Shelton
— Kit
Elizabeth Jackson
— Rachael Gene
John McConnell
— Mr. Mitchell
Lenore Banks
— Mrs. Broomstead
Mark Adam
— Uncle Mike
Gary Grubbs
— Judge Mackin
Tammi Arender
— TV Reporter
Annalise Basso
— Cousin Alice
Jake Austin Walker
— Older Orphan Boy
J.D. Evermore
— Oliver 'Pap' Blake
Cyrus Thompson
— Younger Boy #1
Michael P. Sullivan
— Mr. Gene