Derek Babb
— Chris
Terissa Kelton
— Maggie
Marc Wasserman
— Jack
Reece Everett Ryan
— Young Chris
Leslie Solcher
— Young Maggie
Sarah England
— Pat
Mike Donis
— Paul
Easton Bentley
— Youngest Tom
Andy Bertelsen
— Trey
Hannah Borel
— Tina
Sydne Clark
— Young Jess
Andrea Dettling
— Sue
Emory Duncan
— Young Paul
Alex Escobar
— Youngest Jess
Jake Esparza
— Younger Trey
Orion Gallagher
— Bartender
Linus Gibson
— Youngest Paul
Allison Gregory
— Young Aunt Karen
David Harrod Jr.
— Young Jack
Logan House
— Younger Chris
Anjelica Hymel
— Missy
Vicky Illk
— Jess
Billy Kring
— Judge Saunders
Nick Loritsch
— Bobby
Taylor Luke
— Young Tom
Arthur Marroquin
— Steve
Janet Mayson
— Mrs. Legron
Mark McCarver
— Park Dad
Jennifer Nicole
— Park Mom
Rob Novak
— Tommy