Ben Platt
— Scott
Lola Kirke
— Cindy
Debs Howard
— Julia
Yvette Nicole Brown
— Cookie
Alphonso McAuley
Andy Thompson
— Lawyer
Chad Willett
— Leeland Weaver
Lynda Boyd
— Mom
Bronwen Smith
— Support Group Leader
Jason McKinnon
— Policeman
Ben Andrusco-Daon
— Young Scott
Amanda Fix
— Young Cindy
Rohan Campbell
— Ice Cream Scooper