Rob Lowe
— David
Mckenna Grace
— Emma
Sarah Dugdale
— Chloe
Marci T. House
— Mrs. Ellis
Lorne Cardinal
— Brian
Chris Shields
— Sheriff Peterson
Cara Buono
— Angela
Patty McCormack
— Dr. March
Shauna Johannesen
— Maggie Curtis
Luke Roessler
— Milo
Robert Egger
— Mr. Curtis
John Emmet Tracy
— Mark Wiggins
Kate Isaac
— Leslie
Carly Bentall
— David's Wife
Lucas Steagall
— Kyle
Nevis Unipan
— Girl #1
Anna Dickey
— Girl #2
Juliet Hindle
— Girl #3
Harold Weathersbee
— Hero Wasp
Ema Mlinar
— Singing Student (uncredited)