Erin Cahill
— Megan
Justin Bruening
— Nash
Catherine Corcoran
— Audrey
Ashlyn Alessi
— Toy Store Teen (uncredited)
Rob Figueroa
— George
Samarah Conley
— Ivy
Ann Osmond
— Peggy
Chantal Maurice
— Lane
Kinsey Bowen
— Young Ivy
Rachel Rhodes-Devey
— Bethany
Jim O'Hare
— Daniel
Alan Pontes
— Brandon
Daniel Ferrara
— Randy
Adline Jennings
— Christmas Shopper (Uncredited)