Stephen Baldwin
— Chad Chase
Donald Faison
— Jonathan
Erin Cahill
— Carla Finney
Chynna Phillips
— Mrs. Cameron
Isabella Hofmann
— Sue
Joey Fatone
— Tino
Tessie Santiago
— Jennifer
Andrew Morgado
— (voice)
Stacey Arwen Raab
— Church Member
Michael Monks
— Pastor Skip Finney
Samantha Baldwin
— Girl in Confessional
London Fuller
— London
Andriana Manfredi
— Gretchen
Ryan O'Quinn
— DJ Jazzy Carl
Diana Matlak
— Youth Worker
Bob Sáenz
— Bernard
Bridget Albaugh
— Sheila
Sedona Fuller
— Sedona
Brandy Futch
— Reporter
Dennis Nicomede
— Church Member
Harvey B. Jackson
— Church Member
Wes Halula
— Mort
Thor Ramsey
— Guy Sides
Christian Janner
— Guy in Church
Todd Wilkerson
— Dr. Knott
Christopher Shawn Shaw
— Efficient Stagehand
Apollo Garza
— Church Goer
Ricky Titus-Lam
— Jeremy
Clancy McCartney
— Blaise
John McGalliard
— Laser Tag Stud