Anna Margaret Hollyman
— Sister Aimee
Michael Mosley
— Kenny
Andrea Suarez Paz
— Rey
Macon Blair
— Harold McPherson
Amy Hargreaves
— Sister Semple
Julie White
— Minnie Kennedy
Luce Rains
Lee Eddy
— Hazel
Bill Wise
— Billy Sunday
Nathan Zellner
— Butch
David Born
— Sheriff
Luis Bordonada
— Officer Fernandez
Carlton Caudle
— Sister Aimee Believer
Gary Teague
— Sister Aimee Believer
Justin Arnold
— John Jack
Shane Jacobsen
— Robert P. Shuler
Jordan Elsass
— Nelson Lorris
Thom Hallum
— Peacock