Cropsey

Joshua Zeman

— Himself

Barbara Brancaccio

— Herself

Bill Ellis

— Himself - Professor of Folklore, Penn State

Dorothy D'Eletto

— Herself - Archivist & Researcher

Geraldo Rivera

— Himself - Reporter (archive footage)

Karen Schweiger

— Herself - Jennifer Schweiger's Mother

David Navarro

— Himself - Former Newscaster

Donna Cutugno

— Herself - Founder, Friends of Jennifer

Ralph Aquino

— Himself - Retired Detective, NYPD

Bobby Jensen

— Himself - Retired Detective, NYPD

Ernie Anastos

— Himself - Reporter (archive footage)

Andre Rand

— Himself - Suspect

Jim Callaghan

— Himself - Former Editor, Staten Island Eagle

Jim Dolan

— Himself - Reporter (archive footage)

Theresa Doyle

— Herself - Searcher for Jennifer

Ed Armstrong

— Himself - Holly Ann Hughes's Brother

Sean Hughes

— Himself - Holly Ann Hughes's Brother (archive footage)

Peter Hughes

— Himself - Holly Ann Hughes's Father

Holly Cederholm

— Herself - Holly Ann Hughes's Mother

Ken Schweiger

— Himself - Jennifer Schweiger's Father

John O'Brien

— Himself - Reporter, Staten Island Advance

Duane Felton

— Himself - Defense Attorney for Andre Rand

Larry Simon

— Himself - Defense Attorney for Andre Rand

William L. Murphy

— Himself - Staten Island District Attorney

Trina Cutugno

— Herself - Donna's Daughter

Devin Cutugno

— Himself - Donna's Son

Jimmy Rassias

— Himself - Former Clerk, Port Richmond Deli

Kristine Gosling

— Herself - Det. Sgt. Missing Persons Squad, Long Term Cases, NYPD

Luis Rivera

— Himself - Retired Canine Officer, NYPD

Frank Saez

— Himself - Ret. Det. Missing Persons Squad, Long Term Cases, NYPD