Erik Nelson
— John Newton
Lunden De'Leon
— Aminata
Rob Springer
— Older Samuel Watson
Quinten Johnson
— Tribesman
Amber Dawn Fox
— Elizabeth Scatliffe Newton
Lilly Nelson
— Bar Wench
W. Scott Parker III
— Captain Philip Carteret
John Jackman
— Old John Newton
Landon Wall
— Young Samuel Watson
Jim McKeny
— Mr. Chapman
Edison Skinner
— Billy Prowse
Spyder MacDonald
— Captain Phelps
Folaranmi Afolayan
— Peyai