Kaley Wheless
— Frances Ferguson
Nick Offerman
— Narrator
Keith Poulson
— Nick
David Krumholtz
— Group Therapy Leader
Martin Starr
— Mel
Jennifer Prediger
— Mom
Bill Wise
— Parole Officer
John Gatins
— Warden
Dante Harper
— Cognitive Behavioral Therapist
Megan Jerabek
— Carmen
Jake French
— The Boy
Jack William Marshall
— Detective
Yoko Lawing
— Detective
Zefrey Throwell
— Community Service Leader
Emmy Harrington
— Piper