John Turturro
— Sam Giancana
Mary-Louise Parker
— Phyllis McGuire
Elias Koteas
— Butch Blasi
Maury Chaykin
— Tony Accardo
Louis Del Grande
— Chuckie English
Deborah Duchêne
— Christine McGuire
Larissa Laskin
— Dorothy McGuire
Richard Blackburn
— Police Captain
Christopher Barry
— Photographer
Amanda Blitz
— Annette Giancana
Renessa Blitz
— Francine Giancana
Kelly Bodanis
— Doris
Valerie Boyce
— Showgirl
Bob Clout
— Mr. McGuire
Stuart Clow
— Vince Inserra
Bill Cross
— Robert Maheu
Reg Dreger
— Wadden
Todd Duckworth
— Reporter #2
Greg Ellwand
— William Roemer
Neil Foster
— Reporter
Ron Gabriel
— Frederick Jones
Carole Galloway
— Mrs. McGuire
Yamit Geiger
— Bonnie Giancana
Sam Grana
— Johnny Roselli
Graham Harley
— Introducer
Howard Jerome
— Russian Louie
Nahanni Johnstone
— Carlene Delfano
Patrick Jude
— Frank Sinatra
Brian Kaulback
— U.S. Marshal
David Keeley
— Ralph Hill