Dave Davis
— Stanley Martin
Karli Hall
— Audrey Martin
Erika Chase
— Rat
Kristen Ariza
— Agent Ortiz
Julian Moser
— Teen Nicholas Martin
Brad Greenquist
— Cardinal Degal
Ezra Buzzington
— Father Hill
Timothy V. Murphy
— Father Flynn
Michael Villar
— Frank Collins
Beau Boyd
— Young Nicholas Martin
John Garet Stoker
— Chris Silva
Maryna Bennett
— Rose Patterson
Jessica Gardner
— Emily Harker
Ahmed Mawas
— Sayid Aboud
Kenzo Lee
— Jeff Ellison
Carolyn Alise
— Anna
Luke Adams
— Delivery Man
Catherine Toribio
— Roxanne
Nyell Segura
— John
Pat Asanti
— Father Russo
Steven Lee Allen
— Resurrected Man
Ilca Andrade
— Good Morning America Host
Michael Antosy
— Peter
Tommy Bechtold
— One Life Activist #1
Greg Bryan
— News Anchor
Paige Elson
— Journalist
Tyler Faurlin
— Karl
Ari Frenkel
— Adam Paradise
Chris Gann
— Officer Preston
Krystin Goodwin
— Leslie Steel