David Arquette
— Sgt. Ed Croswell
Danny A. Abeckaser
— Joe Barbara
Jennifer Esposito
— Natalie Passatino
P.J. Byrne
— Vincent Vasisko
Jamie-Lynn Sigler
— Josephine Barbara
Gino Cafarelli
— Carmine Galante
Sasha Feldman
— Dominick
Anthony DeSando
— Mike Miranda
Robert Davi
— Vito Genovese
Nick Cordero
— Vincent Gigante
James McCaffrey
— Chief Lane
Kyle Stefanski
— Joe Gallo
Garry Pastore
— Albert Anastasia
Diana Madison
— Maria in the Kitchen
Katrine Hoyt
— Josephine's Mother
Michael Lombardi
— Mobster
Bo Dietl
— Irving Bozeman Esq.