Greg Kinnear
— Phil
Emily Mortimer
— Alicia
Taylor Schilling
— Sam
Kurt Fuller
— Jerome
Bradley Whitford
— Michael Fisk
Luke Wilson
— Detective Welling
April Cameron
— Rahel
Megan Charpentier
— Molly McGuire
Sarah Dugdale
— Kara Fisk
Jay Duplass
— Malcolm
Robert Forster
— Bing Fisk
Christina Jastrzembska
— Mrs. Konwiser
Jagen Johnson
— Booze Clerk
Angela Moore
— Nurse
Nicole Oliver
— Rosemary
William B. Davis
— Father Grant
Rukiya Bernard
— Nora
Peter Bryant
— Cop
Kirby Morrow
— Childhood Friend
Brittany Mitchell
— Nurse 2 / Pizza Server
Alex Trebek
— Alex Trebek
Doug Abrahams
— Maître D'