Luke Barnett
— Luke
Tanner Thomason
— Tanner
Jason Alexander
— Nicky Steele
Lance Reddick
— Pastor Mike
Carly Craig
— Brandy
David Koechner
— Butch Savage
Christoph Sanders
— Hoyt
Danielle Nicolet
— Tiffany
Lisa Schwartz
— Lisa
Richard Riehle
— Herman
Marlon Young
— Marlon
Lynn Downey
— The Astronaut
Christopher Rodriguez Marquette
— Hans
Danny Woodburn
— Jimmy
Aliza Pearl
— Trisha
David Ury
— Gerry
Margaret Cho
— Jane
Donald Paul
— Ryan
Ashlynn Yennie
— Ashlynn
Brooklyn Rome Bosso
— Young Luke
Dexter Hobert
— Young Tanner
Ryan Harrison
— Ezor
Frank Smith
— Troy
Dan Mahoney
— Danny
Mark Borchardt
— Mark
Nadia Bjorlin
— Katie
Chris Mann
— Felix
Christopher Wonder
— Captain Wonder
Cheik Letang
— Cheik
Kevin Dewitt
— Kevin 'Mother Fucking' Dewitt