Chazz Palminteri
— Paul Castellano
Clancy Brown
— Andris Kurins
Angela Alvarado
— Gloria Olarte
Jay O. Sanders
— Joseph O'Brien
Daniel Benzali
— Bruce Mouw
Richard Foronjy
— Tommy Bilotti
Mark Margolis
— Piney Armone
Steven Bauer
— Vito Genovese
Patricia Mauceri
— Nina Castellano
Vince Corazza
— Philip Castellano
Angelo Tucci
— Paul Castellano Jr.
Tony Nappo
— Gene Gotti
Sonny Marinelli
— John Gotti
Philip Williams
— Nino Gaggi
Yani Gellman
— Young Paul Castellano
William DeMeo
— Young Carlo Gambino
James Villani
— Young Neil Dellacroce
Karen Goberman
— Young Nina Manno
Louis Di Bianco
— Joey Bazzini
James Downing
— Agent Bledsoe
Michael A. Miranda
— Roy DeMeo
Dominic Cuzzocrea
— Stanza
Vito Rezza
— Angelo Ruggerio
Gerry Mendicino
— Father Vicente
Layton Morrison
— Sacco Tambone
Reagan Pasternak
— NYU Student
Lucy Filippone
— Mott Street Woman
Renato Rizzuti
— Marco
Ron Gabriel
— Tommy Agro
Peter Haworth
— Agent Riley