Ellie Church
— Eve (segment born again)
Donna Pieroni
— Seretta (segment lunch ladies)
Kelly Keaton
— Vice Principal (segment lunch ladies)
Mike C. Nelson
— Tex (segment horrific)
Ella Schaefer
— Bailey (segment killer kart)
Mary Manofsky
— LouAnne (segment lunch ladies)
Christine Rodriguez
— Cass (segment killer kart)
Ray Bouchard
— Hale (segment killer kart)
Jaysen P. Buterin
— The Big Guy (segment born again)
Michael Dalmon
— Lars' Dad (segment death metal)