Anastasia Elfman
— Babysitter (segment "Overkill")
Jennifer Nangle
— Malvolia (segment "Malvolias Halloween Monster Marathon")
London Grace
— Mrs McClaron ("A Samhain Liturgy") / Sister Mary ("Sister Mary")
Bianca Allaine
— The Woman (segment "Treaters")
Matt Block
— The Man / Devil (segment "Sister Mary")
Lauren Fogle
— Hot Chick (segment "Overkill")
Jordan Beltz
— Allison (segment "Treaters")
Sable Griedel
— Kira (segment "Treaters")
Marissa Sabatucci
— Rachel (segment "Treaters")
Adam Hershberger
— Narrator (segment "Treaters") (voice
Mark Combs
— Christine (segment "Trucksquatch")
William Davis
— The Husband (segment "The Candy Taker")
Greg Palinkas
— The Friend (segment "The Candy Taker")
Angelina Prendergast
— The Screamer (segment "The Candy Taker")
Christopher Hoban
— Luis (segment "The October Kids")
Lexi Breuer
— Tara (segment "The October Kids")
Emily Swenson
— Jenna (segment "The October Kids")
R.J. Wagner
— Stan (segment "A Samhain Liturgy")
Chad Bruns
— Tim (segment "Treaters")
Gabriel Bulthaup
— Baby (segment "Sister Mary")
Tim Novotny
— Creature / Cocaine Guy #2 (segment "A Samhain Liturgy")
Tania Henderson
— Holly's Mom (segment "A Samhain Liturgy")
Ty Sells
— Cameron (segment "A Samhain Liturgy")
Rhema Srihartiti
— Holly (segment "A Samhain Liturgy")
Zeke Hanson
— Police Officer (segment "The October Kids")
Jessica Breuer
— Kevin's Mom (segment "The October Kids")
Maddox Breuer
— Kevin (segment "The October Kids")