Falling in Love Again

Elliott Gould

— Harry Lewis (Present Day)

Susannah York

— Sue Lewis (Present Day)

Kaye Ballard

— Mrs. Lewis (1940's)

Stuart Paul

— 'Pompadoure' (Young Harry Lewis) (1940's)

Michelle Pfeiffer

— Sue Wellington (1940's)

Robert Hackman

— Mr. Lewis (1940's)

Herbert Rudley

— Mr. Wellington (1940's)

Marian McCargo

— Mrs. Wellington (1940's)

Steven Paul

— Stan the Con (1940's)

Tallie Cochrane

— Hooker (Present Day)

Patrick Wright

— Pat the Cop (1940's)

Bonnie Paul

— Hilary Lewis (Present Day)

Tony O'Dell

— Donny Lewis (Present Day)

Ben Frank

— Cabbie #1 (Present Day)

John Diehl

— Beaver (1940's)

David Caruso

— Neighborhood boy (uncredited)

Pete Schrum

— Meatloaf (Present Day)

Marvin Katzoff

— Como (1940's)

Alan Solomon

— Max the Brain (1940's)

Daniel Davies

— Meatloaf (1940's)

Mickey Cherney

— Ben Herman (1940's)

Mort Schwartz

— Hymie the Bookie (1940's)

Al Bordighi

— Como's Father (1940's)

Twink Caplan

— Malinda (1940's)

Shel Goldstein

— Scrap Drive Leader - 1940's

Walter G. Zeri

— Tough Guy

Mickey Gatlin

— Cabbie #2 (Present Day)

Terrence Evans

— Beaver (Present Day)