Sam Elliott
— Marshall Bill Speakes
Craig Sheffer
— Jack Cooper
Linda Fiorentino
— Sarah O'Rourke
Frank Whaley
— Walter Cooper
John Furlong
— Zeb Hollister
Bradley Whitford
— Tommy Donnelly
Gretchen Becker
— Con Woman in Saloon
Robin Westphal
— Mamie Hollister
Cecile Krevoy
— Con Woman in Saloon
Andrea Camarena-Lindsay
— Katrin
Malissa Feruzzi
— Kate Jessie
Rockne Tarkington
— Packo
Boots Southerland
— Scar Face Leader
Sam Gauny
— Wells Fargo Clerk
Jeff O'Haco
— Frenchy
Jill Momaday
— Janie