Jance Enslin
— Andy Cady
Carly Pope
— Angela Cady
Alyssa Sutherland
— Dana Cady
Alison Thornton
— Bethany Forrest
Bryan Greenberg
— Dylan Cady
William R. Moses
— Principal Mullins
Michael Gladis
— Michael Kennedy
Jim True-Frost
— Pastor Shane
William Popp
— Deputy Johnson
Remington Moses
— Melanie Hansen
Blaine Maye
— Brian Ward
Allen Wall
— Freak at the Carnival
Scott Matheny
— State Trooper
Quinn Hemphill
— Amber Ryan
Bernie Sheredy
— Dr. Roger Wagner
Dannielle Rose
— Religious Woman
Nathan Wallace
— Paul Winters
Amber Anne
— Church Choir / Swim Team
Kevin A. Wall
— Carnival Freak
Daniel Rayome
— Fairgoer
Nolan Callahan
— Lifeguard / student
Michael Barbour
— Sheriff Dell