Malcolm Barrett
— Derrick
Lyndie Greenwood
— Susan
Jonah Ray Rodrigues
— Matt
Felicia Day
— Molly
Gavin Stenhouse
— Bennie Taylor
Wil Wheaton
— David
Rachel Bloom
— Ellie
Motoki Maxted
— Jax
Amir Talai
— Amir
Laurel Toupal
— Becky
Ben Weinswig
— Andy
Willow Beuoy
— Lauren
Alexander Ward
— Animal Pooka
Gene Freeman
— Demon Pooka
Ken Dickason Sr.
— Bar Patron
Lucas Hyde
— Bartender
Jessie Epstein
— Pooka Livestreamer
Harrison Meloeny
— Andy's Colleague
Laurie Perez
— Reporter