Fyvush Finkel
— Moshe
Suzy Kohane
— Paige
Jon Osbeck
— The Ba'al Shem Tov / Rabbi Eizik Taub
Matisyahu
— Self
Danny Maseng
— Self
James Aaron Tecumseh Sinclair
— Card Player 1
Dwayne Blackaller
— Hasidic Student / Card Player 2
Todd Delman
— Card Player 3
Susan Bonowitz
— Mother
Brad Clapper
— Traditional Talmud Student
Brad Keplinger
— Cemetery Hasid
Gaynelle W. Sloman
— Mourner