Phil Brooks
— CM Punk
Rick Blood Sr.
— Ricky Steamboat
Scott Colton
— Colt Cabana
Jamin Pugh
— Jay Briscoe
Mark Pugh
— Mark Briscoe
Danny Lopez
— Dan Maff
Benjamin Whitmer
— BJ Whitmer
Christopher Guy
— Himself
Rick Diaz
— Ricky Reyes
John Raymond Rivera
— Rocky Romero
Daniel Solwold Jr.
— Austin Aries
Christopher Lindsey
— Roderick Strong
Brian Kendrick
— Spanky
Patrick Martin
— Alex Shelley
James Guffey
— Jimmy Rave
Steve Corino
— Himself
Oman Tortuga
— Himself
Eddie Villa
— Fast Eddie
Michael Mayo, Jr
— Mike Kruel
Christopher Scoville
— Jimmy Jacobs
Adam Pearce
— Himself
John Cena
— WWE Champion John Cena
Shelly Martinez
— Ariel
Kevin Fertig
— Thorn