Mick Foley
— Himself
Nuufolau Joel Seanoa
— Samoa Joe
Daniel Solwold Jr.
— Austin Aries
Scott Colton
— Colt Cabana
Christopher Lindsey
— Roderick Strong
Jack Miller
— Jack Evans
Matt Knowles
— HC Loc
Anthony F. DeVito
— Himself
Kevin Dunn
— Dunn
Kirby Marcos
— Marcos
Brian Brower
— Dixie
Brandon Garver
— Himself
Adam Brower
— Izzy
John Stagikas
— John Walters
Jamar Shipman
— Jay Lethal
Brandon Silvestry
— Low Ki
Nelson Rodriguez Erazo
— Homicide
William Hunter Johnston
— Delirious
Mitsunobu Kikuzawa
— Ebetaroh
James Guffey
— Jimmy Rave
Phil Brooks
— CM Punk
Matthew Hardy
— Himself
Daniel Covell
— Christopher Daniels
Jamie Noble
— James Gibson
Bryan Danielson
— Himself
Kenta Kobashi
— Himself
Steve Corino
— Himself
Allen Jones
— AJ Styles
Matthew Joseph Korklan
— Matt Sydal
Chris Parks
— Abyss