Peter Banifaz
— Peter
Casey Feigh
— Casey Flood
Ali Ghandour
— Ali
Matthew Gray Gubler
— Franklin
Mary Holland
— Beth
Lauren Lapkus
— Judith
Ego Nwodim
— Pamela
Rebecca Lee
— Rebecca
Betsy Sodaro
— Bomber
David Theune
— Dave
Kimia Behpoornia
— Kimia
Brittany Giles
— Brittany
Adrian Snow
— Brittany's Mom
Londale Theus Jr.
— Boss
Pam Murphy
— Tammy O'Reilly
Jacob Womack
— Womack
Jennie Pierson
— Jennie
Josh Simpson
— Josh
Connie Shin
— Connie
Erich Tamola
— Erich
Lamar Woods
— Reenactment Bowler
Santina Muha
— Reenactment Teammate
Holly Prazoff
— Reenactment Teammate
Claudio Saavedra
— Reenactment Teammate
Cart Tart
— Carl