Vincent Chiaramonte
— Kevin O'Neil
Lauren-Marie Taylor
— Vickie Godish
Kristiana Tottas
— Faye Godish
Marygrace Smith
— Jessica Godish
Nick Del Bianco
— Wes Burrows
Isabelle Calpakis
— Lead Detective
Gregory Calpakis
— Second Lead Detective
Deanna Zimmer
— Detective Marlboro
Stephanie Trefcer
— Detective Tentacles
Annmarie DePinto
— Detective Jones
Corey Weissman
— Detective Stevens
Jeffrey Caban
— Officer Dumptruck
Ilia Krisulas
— Officer Seashelves
Francesco DePinto
— Mike
William Seaquist
— Billy
Eric Villamar
— Eric
Brody Black
— Trick-or-Treater Damien
Tiffany Ciena
— Cheerleader Girlfriend
Vincent DePinto
— Lair Victim
Michael DeMatteis
— Bar Patron 1
Matthew Cohen
— Bar Patron 3
Michael Zverina
— Onlooker 1
Arber Jashari
— Onlooker 2
Dominick Muschello
— Onlooker 3
Marvin Zorrilla
— Onlooker 4
Brittany Halili
— Onlooker 5
Vincent Steo
— Onlooker 6