Colin Hanks
— Ben Keller
Ari Graynor
— Lucy St. Martin
Ann-Margret
— Pauline Keller
Jeffrey Tambor
— Detective Harold Waylon
Adam J. Harrington
— Steve Mason
Mimi Rogers
— Ms. Brand
Allison Mackie
— Grace
Tom Amandes
— Jonathan
Michelle Davidson
— Leslie Singer
Olivia Sather
— Shannon
Eric Kirchberger
— Sunny Mart Clerk
Heather Marie Marsden
— Allison
Bryan McClure
— Sandwich Guy
Bennett Wright
— 8 year old Ben
Lena Noel Krussel
— 8 year old Lucy
Thom Sibbitt
— Mechanic
Jill Peterson
— Woman
Cullen Chollett
— Man
Virginia Kincaid
— Another Woman
Ryle Smith
— Another Man
Michael Arata
— Man with Piña Colada
Olivia Johnson
— Woman Eating Cheese Fingers
Sean Modica
— Chip
Angelea Jenson
— Female Anchor
Patrick Combs
— Male Anchor
Jeanne Averill
— Sales Lady
Bernie Clark
— Older Man
Kay Clark
— Older Woman
Meghan Strange
— Woman Eating Celery Sticks
Leanne Hill Carlson
— Shanna