Adam Buck
— Young Steve
Cameron Judd
— Young Chet
Andrew Herriage
— Older Steve
Makenna Weyburne
— Sue
Kayla Elizabeth
— Lisa
Vanessa Leonard
— Ms. Lewis
Wes Allen
— Mike
Jeff Frey
— Don Jamison
Sarah Bertz Thomas
— Older Jessica
Monica Hiris
— Ms. Talmadge
Michael Cochran
— Wedding Officiant
Jenna Bolton
— Jen
Tyson Hughes
— Young Ron
Gabriel Rios-Hannon
— 1980s Dance DJ
Denny Crum
— Jamie Sims
Maddie Zellmer
— Deborah Alvin
David E. Dargartz
— Scott
Elliott Kreim
— Barry
Zoe Cross-Nelms
— Young Jessica
Tommy Bilczo
— Tim (as Tommy Bilzco)
Nolan Tiech
— Trevor
Brooke Seddon
— Kristi
Fred LeFebvre
— Radio DJ
James Cels Bragg
— Older Ron
Rebecca Prothero Krueger
— Ms. Stark
Chase Will
— Older Chet
Mark Owen
— Mr. Hubbard
Christopher Boyer
— Ricky
Clinton LaForest
— John
Jacob Goodson
— Adam