Sarah Paulson
— Margaret Bellum
Amiah Miller
— Rose Bellum
Annaleigh Ashford
— Esther Smith
Alona Jane Robbins
— Ollie Bellum
Ebon Moss-Bachrach
— Wallace Grady
Arron Shiver
— Sheriff Bell
Bill Heck
— Henry Bellum
Frances Lee McCain
— Bertha Bell
Courtney Cunningham
— Birdie Mae Bell
James Healy Jr.
— Dr. Cox
Nathan Gariety
— Thomas Smith
Ethan Woodall
— Jacob Smith
Hannah Mosqueda
— Janie
Emily Katherine Ford
— Ada (uncredited)