Peter Pan

Mary Martin

— Peter Pan

Cyril Ritchard

— Mr. Darling / Captain Hook

Kathleen Nolan

— Wendy / Jane

Margalo Gillmore

— Mrs. Darling

Sondra Lee

— Tiger Lily

Heller Halliday

— Liza

Joe E. Marks

— Smee

Norman Shelly

— Nana / Crocodile

Michael Allen

— John

Tom Halloran

— Michael

David Bean

— Slightly

Stanley Stenner

— Curly

Alan Sutherland

— First Twin

Harold Daye

— Second Twin

Ian Tucker

— Tootles

Paris Theodore

— Nibs

Richard Wyatt

— Lion

Joan Tewkesbury

— Ostrich

Peggy Maurer

— Wendy Grown-Up

Robert Vanselow

— Starkey

Richard Winter

— Cecco

Frank Lindsay

— Noodler

Carl Erbele

— Kangaroo

Patricia Wheel

— Narrator