Barbara Cook
— Evelina Applegate
Keith Andes
— Jefferson Calhoun
Carmen Mathews
— Dolly Bloomer
Paul Ford
— Horatio Applegate
Rawn Spearman
— Pompey
Nydia Westman
— Serena Applegate
Patricia Hammerlee
— Daisy
Brock Peters
— Alexander
Dorothy Lang
— Applegate Sister
Margot Moser
— Applegate Sister
Peggy O'Hara
— Applegate Sister
Elise Rhodes
— Octavia Applegate
Paula Stewart
— Julia Applegate
Heywood Hale Broun
— Sheriff
Paul McGrath
— Governor Newton
Frank Overton
— Hamilton Calhoun
Jack Russell
— Joshua
Danny Scholl
— Ebeneezer
James Mitchell
— Principal Dancer - "The Returned Soldier"
Lidija Franklin
— Principal Dancer - "His Girl"
Betty Low
— Principal Dancer - "The Widow"
Emy St. Just
— Principal Dancer - "The Needle Threader"