Katie Kelly
— Kristen
Paola Andino
— Hannah
Michael Lombardi
— Matt
Shannan Wilson
— Clare McKusker
Niko Terho
— Jeff
Myles Clohessy
— Mike
Ken Arnold
— Bill McKusker
Dominic Costa
— Crossover
Abbey Hafer
— Maddie McKusker
Molly Logan Chase
— Mary
Meryl Jones Williams
— Valerie
Jane Stiles
— Anna
Evangeline Young
— Emily
Greg Nutcher
— Officer Burns
Gemma McIlhenny
— Officer Clarkson
Corrie Graham
— Kelly Shay
Liv Adelman
— Mia
Joanne Baron
— Sister Margaret
Booch O'Connell
— Church Member