Judd Nelson
— Pastor Wember
Brian Baumgartner
— Skip Wick
Rhoda Griffis
— Donna
Claire Bronson
— Rebekah
Shawn Parsons
— Chris Angelopolous
Gunner Willis
— Cliff
Shua Jackson
— Roadie
Michael H. Cole
— Jack
Sandra Elise Williams
— Mimi
Jef Holbrook
— Snarky Fan
Andrew Eakle
— Erik
Caleb Hoffmann
— Scotty
Shannon Hutchinson
— Sarah
Wyatt Lenhart
— Michael
Matt Hoffman
— Adult Erik
Blaque Fowler
— Drunk Rocker
Alan Wells
— Perry Minter
Lilly Nelson
— Meg
Christina Leidel
— Amy Grant
James Edward Thomas
— Adult Cliff
Miles Snow
— Dean Wilkie
Pete Penuel
— Adult Michael
Laticia Lee
— Bartender
Sean Freeland
— Kasper Kapelrud