The Penitent Thief

Kevin Sorbo

— King Herod

James Russo

— Castor

Major Dodge

— Gabriel

Stelio Savante

— Tiran

Krista Bradley

— Joanna

Xiomara Bermudez

— Mary

Jay Giannone

— Dismas

Charles "Skeeta" Jenkins

— Melchior

Major Dodge Jr.

— Young Jotham

Randall Tyree Brooks II

— Thomas's Son

James Logan

— Thomas

Daniela Vidaurre

— Adinah

Carter Moore

— Young Yeshua

Nene Nwoko

Adele Marie Pomerenke

Gerardo Davila

Travis Conover

Amir Natan

Wil Crown

Lucas Miles

Chuck Meré

Greg Fallon