Jim Fullington
— Sandman
Tom Laughlin
— Tommy Dreamer
Ted Petty
— "Flyboy" Rocco Rock
Mike Durham
— Johnny Grunge
Scott Levy
— Raven
Michael Manna
— Stevie Richards
Brian Knighton
— Axl Rotten
John Williams
— Ian Rotten
Peter Senerchia
— Taz
Chad Slivenski
— Chad Austin
Charles Scaggs
— 2 Cold Scorpio
Don Haviland
— Hack Meyers
Gary Wolfe
— Pitbull #1
Anthony Durante
— Pitbull #2
Don Adelberg
— "Devious" Donn E. Allen
Dino Sandorff
— Dino Sendoff
Paul Heyman
— Paul E. Dangerously
Nancy Toffoloni
— Woman
Trisa Laughlin
— Beulah McGillicutty
William Sierra
— Bill Alfonso
Francine Meeks
— Francine (Ringside)
John Watson
— Mikey Whipwreck (Appearance)
Mick Foley
— Cactus Jack (Appearance)
Troy Martin
— "The Franchise" Shane Douglas (Appearance)
Jerome Young
— New Jack (Appearance)
Jamal Mustafa
— Mustafa (Appearance)
Al Poling
— 911 (Appearance)