Shirley Jones
— Bunny
Cloris Leachman
— Helen
Louise Fletcher
— Mother Superior
Seymour Cassel
— Stanley
Frank Gorshin
— Ed
Wendie Malick
— Inez
Jill Eikenberry
— Dottie
Austin Pendleton
— Two-Digit Doyle
Shelley Duvall
— Detective Dubrinski
Hallee Hirsh
— Young Theresa
Harry Groener
— Tony
Faye Grant
— Rita
Drew Pillsbury
— Mac / Bake
Jerry Orbach
— Waltz Contest Announcer
Ursula Burton
— Theresa
Maria Burton
— Ramona
Cameron Watson
— Patrick
Vincent O'Neill
— Monsignor Dailey
Maureen Porter
— Rosalie Annunciata
Gabrielle B. Burton
— Young Bunny
Jennifer Burton
— Young Helen
Buddy Bolton
— Young Ed
Tamera Gindlesperger
— Young Dottie
Kate LoConti
— Young Inez
Abby Royle
— Young Rita
Neal Moeller
— Young Tony
Amy Wieczorek
— Mrs. MacNamara
Kathleen Betsko Yale
— Poor Woman
Carolyn Ferrini
— First Dance Couple Woman
Roger V. Burton
— Second Dance Couple Man