Andrew Rogers
— Ethan Dulane
Ashley Brinkman
— Hope McGregor
Charles Cain
— Young Gabe
Cody Calafiore
— Gabe Corsetti
Chris Owen
— Matt Clark
Paulie Calafiore
— Tommy
Alix Kermes
— Joy McGregor
Stink Fisher
— Frank McGregor
David Eggers II
— Eddie Morris
Stefanie Bloom
— Grace McGregor
Catherine Cain
— Young Hope
Nicholas Corleto
— Two Sisters Ranch Guest
Donna Drake
— Aunt Faith
Andrea Evans
— Joan Elkhart
Vivica A. Fox
— Amanda Parkington
Fabienne Gardiner
— Christmas Tree Customer
Abigail Hawk
— Denise
Colton Kraese
— Two Sisters Ranch Guest
Gunnar Kraese
— Two Sisters Ranch Guest
Philip Kraese
— Two Sisters Ranch Guest
Kaitlyn LaGrega
— Christmas Tree Customer
Kylie MacDonald
— Ethan's Fan
Mango
— King
Monika Mannix
— Two Sisters Ranch Guest
Allison Mullaney
— Young Joy
Kenney Myers
— Lee Elkhart
Jayne O'Toole
— Two Sisters Ranch Guest
Dawn Petty
— Two Sisters Ranch Guest
Jaiden Riley
— Two Sisters Ranch Guest
Judith Riley
— Two Sisters Ranch Guest