Ryan Wesley Gilreath
— Tony Mirakul
Annie Kalahurka
— Amana Davenport Mirakul
Laura E. Mock
— Emily Vanderslice Seacker
Chris Petty
— Joseph Seacker
Victoria McDevitt
— Jessie Seacker
Michael Shawn Starks
— Simon Wasp a.k.a. Doug Dineen
Sean Cook
— Deacon Blue
Christine Jones
— Sister Mary Rose
Raymond A. Smith
— Father Stan Pacific
Larry Cole
— Father Nicholas Barkley
David Baum
— Father Leonard Defazio 'Fr. Def'
A. John Beeler
— Magician
Arizona Craycraft
— Rachel Brony
Lindsey Marlin
— Nurse Abby
Tom Morton
— Father O'Toole
Mitch Teemley
— Archbishop Jonathan Seemley
Mike Haley
— Man at Bar
Ryley Emory-Hays
— Student 'Mary'
Kameron Laguna
— Student 'Gabriel'
Danny Rigney
— Limo Driver
Daphne Steele
— Toddler
Thomas W. Wenz
— Father of the Bride
Rosemary Wenz
— Mother of the Bride